When it comes to asset protection trusts, the discussion with my clients almost always comes down to whether or the Nevada Asset Protection Trust (NAPT) or the Special Power of Appointment Trust (SPA Trust) is a better fit. Of course, it's always determined on a case by case basis and I will emphatically direct you to my disclaimer at the bottom of the blog before reading further, but there are certainly a couple common factors to consider when deciding.
Both trusts are spendthrift trusts designed to prevent creditors from reaching trust assets and endow the trustee with absolute discretion over distribution decisions. Where they differ is the self-settled aspect. The "Nevada" of the NAPT refers to the provision in NRS 166 that allows a grantor (aka settlor or trustor) to also be a beneficiary. Nevada and a few other states offer this nuance which was inspired by offshore trusts that do the same. By using a domestic trust, the grantor avoids the stigma of placing assets outside the U.S. and does not have to file notice forms with the IRS.
The SPA Trust is not self-settled, instead relying on the power of appointment to appoint assets back to the grantor, should the need arise.
GRANTOR ACCESS
The NAPT offers greater access for the grantor because he is treated the same as any beneficiary. The trustee may make distributions at any time to the grantor, giving the grantor the ability to protect trust assets, but still be able to enjoy the income or principal at any time. The power of appointment used by the SPA Trust is not used the same way. Instead it's generally a single use tool to receive some or all of the trust assets without being a beneficiary of the trust.
NON-RESIDENT GRANTOR
A grantor can appoint a professional, Nevada resident trustee to the trust to qualify the trust to be governed by Nevada law. That has its own inherent benefits, but is mandatory for the NAPT if the grantor is not a Nevada resident. Even when all of the trust assets are located in Nevada, I still recommend a resident trustee for a non-resident grantor. The risk for non-resident grantors, though, is the possibility that a non self-settled trust jurisdiction could apply their own trust law in a suit against the trust, extinguishing the asset protection provided to the grantor-beneficiary. Though I haven't seen it happen, in theory it could. Nevada residents are protected from this event, but non-residents with self-settled trusts can't be sure.
As already discussed, since the grantor is not a beneficiary of a SPA Trust, such a concern is moot.
CONCLUSION
Also important to the decision is how business entities will be used to support the strategy, the availability of a trustworthy distribution trustee to the grantor, and more. There is no right answer for every circumstance so it is important to discuss these matter with an experienced asset protection attorney who will intelligently guide you through the process. Most important to the entire process is timing. As always, transfers to an irrevocable trust should be done when the waters are calm to ensure the most effective arrangement.
Wednesday, January 25, 2012
Monday, January 16, 2012
Do I need to retitle ALL of my bank accounts into the name of my trust?
As has been mentioned before, funding a trust is the hand to the glove of trust instrument preparation. Just because you have your revocable trust instrument drafted and executed doesn't guarantee your beneficiaries will not have to probate your estate. You have to actually change title of your assets into the name of the trust to complete the process. It's a critical step and a subject I emphasize and review the process of during each document signing with my clients.
But the question often arises, do I need to transfer ALL of my liquid accounts into the trust? No, so long as you are aware of the consequences. Take a bank account, for instance. You have a couple options. Do nothing and upon the death of the account owners the bank will require a court order appointing the rightful beneficiary to those funds. Depending on the balance of that account and/or the size of the probate estate, the could require a significant amount of expense and time to access those funds.
The next best option is to name a "Payable on Death" (aka POD) beneficiary. Now the account is not a probate asset because, by operation of contract, the funds will pass to the named beneficiary upon presentation to the bank of a death certificate and some signed forms. However, should the owner not die, but merely be incapacitated, the account will be frozen since the owner is unable to access the funds him or herself. Were the account owned by the trust and appropriate language was found in the trust instrument, then the successor trustee could access those funds to pay bills or other needs in the stead of the principal. In addition, should the named beneficiary be financially irresponsible or already subject to execution of a civil judgment, those funds could disappear quickly. Finally, should the undocumented intent of the POD designation be that the beneficiary is to distribute those funds among others, that beneficiary could be stuck with the gift tax bill along with the responsibility of dealing with unhappy potential heirs.
The best way to alleviate the above problems and many more is to retitle all accounts into the name of the trust. Now, of course there are certainly circumstances that call for doing something different, but such a decision should only be made after considering all the ramifications of doing so. In fact, I have advised just such a course of action for a client recently. If I am retained to advise and draft your estate plan, I will walk you through the proper course of action for all of your assets. Call my office to set an appointment.
But the question often arises, do I need to transfer ALL of my liquid accounts into the trust? No, so long as you are aware of the consequences. Take a bank account, for instance. You have a couple options. Do nothing and upon the death of the account owners the bank will require a court order appointing the rightful beneficiary to those funds. Depending on the balance of that account and/or the size of the probate estate, the could require a significant amount of expense and time to access those funds.
The next best option is to name a "Payable on Death" (aka POD) beneficiary. Now the account is not a probate asset because, by operation of contract, the funds will pass to the named beneficiary upon presentation to the bank of a death certificate and some signed forms. However, should the owner not die, but merely be incapacitated, the account will be frozen since the owner is unable to access the funds him or herself. Were the account owned by the trust and appropriate language was found in the trust instrument, then the successor trustee could access those funds to pay bills or other needs in the stead of the principal. In addition, should the named beneficiary be financially irresponsible or already subject to execution of a civil judgment, those funds could disappear quickly. Finally, should the undocumented intent of the POD designation be that the beneficiary is to distribute those funds among others, that beneficiary could be stuck with the gift tax bill along with the responsibility of dealing with unhappy potential heirs.
The best way to alleviate the above problems and many more is to retitle all accounts into the name of the trust. Now, of course there are certainly circumstances that call for doing something different, but such a decision should only be made after considering all the ramifications of doing so. In fact, I have advised just such a course of action for a client recently. If I am retained to advise and draft your estate plan, I will walk you through the proper course of action for all of your assets. Call my office to set an appointment.
Wednesday, December 14, 2011
The Importance of a Living Will
I've addresses this issue before (here and here), but it certainly deserves repeating. Forbes recently published a terrific article emphasizing the importance of completing a living will (aka advance health care directive) and what happened to one family without one. To summarize, the deceased suffered a brain aneurysm and soon fell into an irreversible coma. He was essentially brain dead, save minimal brain activity. The family, still suffering from the shock of this event, was then confronted by the hospital who desired to take him off life support and let him die. The family was unsure what he would have wanted and fought to keep him around at least a few days longer to allow them and other out of state family to say their goodbyes. The hospital disagreed and a standoff ensued.
Not much later the minimal brain activity he had left eventually ceased. However, without advance direction from their deceased father, the family was left with significantly greater expense and stress than necessary.
As part of any estate plan I draft, I include a living will. This gives my clients the opportunity to think through and decide what is to be done if they are to fall into an incurable and irreversible condition that, without life sustaining treatment, will shortly result in their death. It is not an enjoyable conversation, but an important decision that will relieve their families from many of the difficulties suffered by the family discussed in the article.
If all you need is the living will by itself, the Nevada Department of Health and Human Services has provided a form along with pages of useful information here.
Not much later the minimal brain activity he had left eventually ceased. However, without advance direction from their deceased father, the family was left with significantly greater expense and stress than necessary.
As part of any estate plan I draft, I include a living will. This gives my clients the opportunity to think through and decide what is to be done if they are to fall into an incurable and irreversible condition that, without life sustaining treatment, will shortly result in their death. It is not an enjoyable conversation, but an important decision that will relieve their families from many of the difficulties suffered by the family discussed in the article.
If all you need is the living will by itself, the Nevada Department of Health and Human Services has provided a form along with pages of useful information here.
Wednesday, November 30, 2011
Choosing a Guardian
Next to deciding how to complete their living wills (pull the plug or keep me on food and water?), choosing guardians for their minor children is the most difficult decision my clients make when performing their estate planning. They look to me for advice and while I can provide a couple guiding suggestions, it's a very personal decision. Ultimately it's up to the client to weigh the perceived parenting abilities, philosophies, religious affiliations, etc. of their potential options to try and make the best decision possible. It's also very common to have two parents who each argue that their own siblings or parents are the better candidates. For these reasons it's critical to create a will, if for nothing else, to unequivocally nominate guardians and avoid fighting among families as to what you two would have wanted.
I came across a great article that will help make the difficult decision a little easier. It's definitely worth the click to read, but to paraphrase, the author states:
1. Stop looking for the perfect guardian. In all likelihood one does not exist, so instead choose someone who meets most of your criteria. Choosing someone is better than doing nothing at all and the selection can always be changed as your kids grow or your chosen guardian gives you reason to look elsewhere.
2. You can't expect the situation to just take care of itself simply because there are so many good options. Upon your death, without a guardian nominated, the fact that so many people are willing and able can lead to infighting amongst the self-proclaimed candidates and the real losers in that battle are the children. Being explicit about your choice prevents the chaos that could arise.
3. A handwritten note may not be enough and probably isn't binding. If you've already made the tough decision, take the extra step and make it official by formally completely your estate plan. At the very least, complete a holographic will that will be valid in probate court. A note is better than nothing, but a family court judge need only take it under advisement and may still choose another person who he finds more appealing in his determination.
4. The author suggests having an open discussion with your choice about your parenting style, post-death financial and living arrangements and other personal, important and relevant subjects. This allows your choice to make an honest decision about their willingness to be a guardian to your children, and will help you to decide if the fit is satisfactory.
While I think this is certainly a reasonable route to take, I generally advise differently if you have several good options. Instead, I would suggest choosing three individuals or couples and placing them in order of priority. In the event you pass away prior to your child reaching the age or majority, the first guardian on your list will have the opportunity to accept the nomination or decline, in which case the next person on the list will be able to step up. This provides you a safety net in the unlikely event the first person you chose declines, but it also avoids the weighty discussion you might have with your choice, as the author suggests. Moreover, a lot of the more difficult factors regarding money fall by the wayside if you have taken proper measures with a living trust to provide for your children and assist your guardian.
As the author emphasizes, do something! While many people believe estate planning is only for those who have a valuable estate to protect and distribute, naming guardians for your children is critical and necessary. Take a moment to consider how your family and friends would respond to the care of your children upon the death of you or you and your spouse. If you can envision any dispute or discord, then take the steps to resolve those problems before they can arise by drafting wills and a living trust.
I came across a great article that will help make the difficult decision a little easier. It's definitely worth the click to read, but to paraphrase, the author states:
1. Stop looking for the perfect guardian. In all likelihood one does not exist, so instead choose someone who meets most of your criteria. Choosing someone is better than doing nothing at all and the selection can always be changed as your kids grow or your chosen guardian gives you reason to look elsewhere.
2. You can't expect the situation to just take care of itself simply because there are so many good options. Upon your death, without a guardian nominated, the fact that so many people are willing and able can lead to infighting amongst the self-proclaimed candidates and the real losers in that battle are the children. Being explicit about your choice prevents the chaos that could arise.
3. A handwritten note may not be enough and probably isn't binding. If you've already made the tough decision, take the extra step and make it official by formally completely your estate plan. At the very least, complete a holographic will that will be valid in probate court. A note is better than nothing, but a family court judge need only take it under advisement and may still choose another person who he finds more appealing in his determination.
4. The author suggests having an open discussion with your choice about your parenting style, post-death financial and living arrangements and other personal, important and relevant subjects. This allows your choice to make an honest decision about their willingness to be a guardian to your children, and will help you to decide if the fit is satisfactory.
While I think this is certainly a reasonable route to take, I generally advise differently if you have several good options. Instead, I would suggest choosing three individuals or couples and placing them in order of priority. In the event you pass away prior to your child reaching the age or majority, the first guardian on your list will have the opportunity to accept the nomination or decline, in which case the next person on the list will be able to step up. This provides you a safety net in the unlikely event the first person you chose declines, but it also avoids the weighty discussion you might have with your choice, as the author suggests. Moreover, a lot of the more difficult factors regarding money fall by the wayside if you have taken proper measures with a living trust to provide for your children and assist your guardian.
As the author emphasizes, do something! While many people believe estate planning is only for those who have a valuable estate to protect and distribute, naming guardians for your children is critical and necessary. Take a moment to consider how your family and friends would respond to the care of your children upon the death of you or you and your spouse. If you can envision any dispute or discord, then take the steps to resolve those problems before they can arise by drafting wills and a living trust.
Wednesday, November 9, 2011
Videotaping the signing of your will
A popular Hollywood depiction of estate planning is the gathering of the family together to watch a video of the wealthy decedent describing his desires for the distribution of his estate. In my career I've only seen that done once and you might be surprised to learn that, independent of a document corroborating the video, the video will is invalid. In fact, video recordings are rarely used in estate planning at all.
The most frequent use of a video camera in the estate planning process is for the purpose of creating video evidence of the mental capacity of a client during his or her signing. As I've mentioned before, testamentary capacity is a critical issue when signing your will and trust. If you lack the requisite mental capacity, then the will or trust could be adjudged invalid. Sometimes an attorney will take the extra precaution of videotaping the signing along with a short question an answer period to prove the testator and/or grantor meets the threshold of mental capacity. Makes sense, doesn't it? If you want to prove to future potential challengers of the validity of the document that the client was of sound mind when signing the document, the best way to do so would be actual visual evidence of the signing itself. Unfortunately, it's not that simple. (Is it ever?)
The first issue with this approach is when to videotape the signing. If the attorney chooses to videotape only certain signings, in those signings he chooses to videotape it raises the presumption that he might believe that there could be some doubt as to the capacity of that specific client. Why would the attorney only record that person's signing to the exclusion of others unless he wasn't himself sure about the client's mental state?
Perhaps, the attorney solves that issue by simply videotaping every signing. Now no one client is treated differently than another. However, in the same way instant replay of a football play isn't always conclusive, the videotaping of an individual may lead different viewers to different conclusions when the absence of the video would leaving nothing to interpret. Or worse, a testator who was perfectly capable of signing her documents could have their validity challenged based on a subjective flaw that an angry disinherited heir and his attorney discover after the fact. Moreover, that challenge could be buffetted by the complaint that not enough of the signing was recorded and that only a favorable clip was preserved by the attorney.
I have never recorded a document signing for a client and for the reasons above, I don't plan to. Attorneys use built in safeguards to assess not only the capacity of the client for him or herself, but also within the documents to avoid challenges based on lack of capacity. I've had to refuse preparation of documents for clients in the past when I determined they would not meet the threshold. It's also why I counsel individuals and families to be proactive about getting their planning done before such a problem can arise.
The most frequent use of a video camera in the estate planning process is for the purpose of creating video evidence of the mental capacity of a client during his or her signing. As I've mentioned before, testamentary capacity is a critical issue when signing your will and trust. If you lack the requisite mental capacity, then the will or trust could be adjudged invalid. Sometimes an attorney will take the extra precaution of videotaping the signing along with a short question an answer period to prove the testator and/or grantor meets the threshold of mental capacity. Makes sense, doesn't it? If you want to prove to future potential challengers of the validity of the document that the client was of sound mind when signing the document, the best way to do so would be actual visual evidence of the signing itself. Unfortunately, it's not that simple. (Is it ever?)
The first issue with this approach is when to videotape the signing. If the attorney chooses to videotape only certain signings, in those signings he chooses to videotape it raises the presumption that he might believe that there could be some doubt as to the capacity of that specific client. Why would the attorney only record that person's signing to the exclusion of others unless he wasn't himself sure about the client's mental state?
Perhaps, the attorney solves that issue by simply videotaping every signing. Now no one client is treated differently than another. However, in the same way instant replay of a football play isn't always conclusive, the videotaping of an individual may lead different viewers to different conclusions when the absence of the video would leaving nothing to interpret. Or worse, a testator who was perfectly capable of signing her documents could have their validity challenged based on a subjective flaw that an angry disinherited heir and his attorney discover after the fact. Moreover, that challenge could be buffetted by the complaint that not enough of the signing was recorded and that only a favorable clip was preserved by the attorney.
I have never recorded a document signing for a client and for the reasons above, I don't plan to. Attorneys use built in safeguards to assess not only the capacity of the client for him or herself, but also within the documents to avoid challenges based on lack of capacity. I've had to refuse preparation of documents for clients in the past when I determined they would not meet the threshold. It's also why I counsel individuals and families to be proactive about getting their planning done before such a problem can arise.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)